|Portrayed by||Kellan Lutz|
|First appearance||Five Years Gone|
|Occupation||Burnt Toast Diner waiter|
At the Burnt Toast Diner, Andy notices that Claire, whom he knows as "Sandra", perks up whenever she sees the President on television and teases her about it, though she remarks that Nathan Petrelli is old enough to be her father. When Andy wonders if Claire is getting cold feet, she assures him that her feet are "very warm" and kisses him. Andy does not know that Mr. Bennet is Claire's adoptive father, and refers to him only as "that creepy guy in glasses" whenever he visits the diner. Later, when Claire learns that her location has been compromised, she implores Andy to elope with her. Andy assures her that he will do anything for her, and leaves to pack his things. However, Claire is taken by Matt Parkman soon after Andy leaves.
- For other uses of Andy, see Andy (disambig).